The IME (Independent Medical Exam): What It Really Is and Why Insurers Request It

Female occupational therapist discusses treatment plan with unrecognizable man

You head to your mailbox to get the mail, and boom, there’s yet another letter making your stomach drop. Yet another doctor's appointment is in your future, but this time it’s something called an independent medical exam. Like the other doctors you’ve already seen aren’t enough? This new doctor is one you’ve never heard of in an office you’ve never been to. That’s kind of the point, though. An independent medical exam in workers’ comp claims involves an outside doctor who examines you and prepares a report with their opinion regarding your condition and future needs.

Key Takeaways

  • Commonly referred to as an “IME,” an independent medical exam in workers’ comp is an official exam requested by the workers’ comp insurer.
  • The employer chooses and pays for the doctor.
  • Insurers will request an IME to support their justification for ending a worker’s benefits.
  • Workers must participate by attending the IME or risk their benefits being suspended until they do.
  • After the exam, the doctor prepares the report and sends it to the insurer.
  • An attorney can review the report for errors and bias.

What an IME Really Is (And Why “Independent” Is a Generous Word)

Despite the term “independent” being in there, don’t be fooled. The doctor doing your independent medical exam in workers’ comp is not an unbiased or neutral third party. They are hired by the workers' comp insurance company. Nobody wants to directly address it, but that means they have an interest in making the insurance company happy. What does that mean for you? It means they could be more likely to prepare a report that supports what the insurance company wants, e.g., you don’t need continued treatment. An IME’s purpose is to determine the nature, extent, and probable duration of the injury, along with the amount of compensation that may be due.

In an Illinois workers’ comp case, an IME is requested under Section 12 of the Illinois Workers' Compensation Act. Despite the insurance company requesting the exam, it is the employer that can choose and pay for the exam. You, as the worker, don’t get a say in which doctor does the exam.

Why Insurers Request an IME

Insurance companies don’t request IMEs for the fun of it. It’s just more paperwork and documentation for everyone. However, that doesn’t mean they won’t request one. There are a few reasons that commonly pop up for why a workers’ comp insurer wants an IME, including:

  • Questioning the necessity of ongoing medical treatment.
  • Claiming the worker doesn’t need further care because they’ve reached their maximum medical improvement (MMI).
  • Disputing the injury being work-related.
  • Looking for justification to cut off Temporary Total Disability (TTD) payments or medical benefits.

As you can see, an independent medical exam in workers’ comp isn’t requested because the employer has a general interest in your health. There are very real reasons that will have a direct impact on the future of your benefits. The outcome of the IME could potentially be the cause of your workers’ comp benefits being cut off.

What Happens to the Report (And Why It Matters)

After you participate in an independent medical exam in workers’ comp, the doctor will prepare a report that goes to the insurer. It’s also common for that report to go to your attorney via email or mail if you have one. That report is crucial because it’s now part of the evidence of the case. What the report says can directly impact the future of your workers’ comp claim.

A report that favors the insurer’s position could be used as justification for cutting off TTD or other medical benefits. The worker is then forced to choose between accepting the cutoff of benefits or contesting the determination of the Illinois Workers' Compensation Commission. Having attorney representation can be helpful because they can review the report for accuracy or bias. If there are issues identified, your lawyer can push back on the report and advocate for you.

Do You Have to Go?

You may not want to, but generally, yes, you have to go to an IME appointment as a part of your Illinois workers’ compensation claim. Digging your heels in and refusing is a bad idea. Under Section 12, if you don’t have a recognized reason for refusing a properly requested exam, your right to benefits could be suspended until you cooperate and do the exam. That doesn’t mean you don’t have any rights. An IME may not be properly requested, and workers can push back on that.

Section 12 provides the right to object to certain examination arrangements, but that doesn’t mean you should ignore the appointment. You may also have a specific reason for your refusal, which is different from unnecessarily obstructing the process. The good news is that the suspension is temporary and not a permanent denial. The suspension of benefits is directly tied to your compliance with attending the IME.

Contact a Chicago Workers' Compensation Attorney

Filing a workers’ compensation claim sounds so simple on its surface: you’re hurt, so you should file a claim. The reality is that the process is full of paperwork, processes, and deadlines. Getting an IME letter doesn’t mean it’s the end of the world or that your case is falling apart. But you also need to know what you’re up against. Stephen Hoffman is your man for walking you through the workers’ compensation process and complying with IME requests. Schedule a free consultation by contacting the office at (773) 944-9737 and stephen@hofflawyer.com to discuss your workers’ comp case.